No. Butter chicken is the mildest dish on most Indian menus in Australia, including ours. It’s made with tomato, butter and cream, and while it contains a long list of spices, it contains almost no chilli. Children eat it happily. If you find butter chicken too hot, either the kitchen has changed the recipe or you’re reacting to something other than chilli.
Spiced and spicy are two different words
This is the thing that trips people up, and it’s worth getting straight before you order anything at an Indian restaurant.
Spiced means the dish has spices in it. Cumin, coriander seed, cardamom, cinnamon, cloves, turmeric, fenugreek. Aromatic and warm. Spicy, the way most Australians use the word, means chilli heat, the burn at the back of your throat.
Butter chicken is heavily spiced and barely spicy at all. There might be a small amount of Kashmiri chilli in the marinade or gravy, and Kashmiri chilli is used almost entirely for its deep red colour rather than its heat. Everything else you’re tasting is aroma, not burn.
What’s actually in it
Chicken gets marinated in yoghurt with ginger, garlic and ground spices, then cooked in the tandoor. The gravy is tomatoes cooked down until they turn sweet, butter, cream, and a pinch of kasoori methi (dried fenugreek leaves) crushed in right at the end.
Every one of those things softens heat rather than adding it. Cream and butter coat your tongue and dull capsaicin. Cooked tomato brings sweetness. Even if a kitchen were heavy handed with the chilli, the dairy would flatten most of it out.
If you want the full breakdown of how it’s put together, we’ve written what is butter chicken separately.
What “mild” means on our menu
Every curry at Ice n Spice is cooked to order at mild, medium or hot. That’s not a marketing line, it’s how the kitchen runs. Jasvinder is from Rajasthan, where the food is genuinely hot, so our “hot” is not a token gesture.
Here’s roughly where things sit:
- Butter Chicken: mild by default. Even our medium version is gentle. Ordering it hot is possible and a bit strange, but people do it.
- Chicken Tikka Masala: a step up from butter chicken even at mild. More garam masala, more warmth.
- Chicken Vindaloo, Prawn Madras, Goat Madras: actual heat. Order these knowing what you’re getting.
- Laal Maas: the Rajasthani lamb dish. This is the hottest thing we cook and we won’t pretend otherwise.
Most families with young kids order butter chicken at mild with a plain butter naan and steamed rice. That combination has never caused a problem in this dining room.
What to order if you want it even milder
Butter chicken is already about as gentle as Indian food gets, but if someone at your table is genuinely sensitive, there are a few moves.
Ask for it without any chilli at all. We can do that. Say it when you order, not when the food arrives.
Order Vegetable Korma or Beef Korma instead. Korma is thickened with cashew paste and cream and is arguably milder than butter chicken, because it doesn’t carry the same tomato acidity. Some people find tomato itself sharp, and korma sidesteps that entirely.
Order Mango Chicken if the person eating is a child. It’s sweeter and mango is a flavour kids already recognise. It’s not a traditional dish and we won’t pretend it is, but it does its job.
Get plenty of rice and a plain butter naan on the table, because they’re the most effective way to take the edge off anything. Yoghurt helps too. Water does not, it spreads capsaicin around your mouth and makes things worse.
What to order if you want the same style with more heat
This is the more common request, honestly. People who’ve been ordering butter chicken for years eventually want something with a bit more going on.
Chicken Tikka Masala is the direct step up. Same tandoor-cooked chicken, tomato base, cream in it, but built on an onion, ginger and garlic gravy with more ground spice and a genuine warmth. We think it’s the better dish and we’ve argued that case in butter chicken vs tikka masala.
Karahi Chicken takes it further again. Cooked in a heavy karahi with capsicum, onion, tomato and whole spices. Drier, sharper, much more assertive. This is closer to what north Indian home cooking actually tastes like.
Chicken Vindaloo if you want heat as the point of the dish. It’s sour and hot from vinegar and chilli, and its origin is contested between Goa and Portuguese influence. Don’t order it as a first move.
You can also just ask for butter chicken at medium or hot. Plenty of people do. It keeps the sweet, creamy character that made you order it in the first place.
Ordering for kids
We get a lot of families, particularly at lunch and particularly during the Carnival of Flowers in September when the CBD fills up. The question we hear most is some version of “will my six year old eat this”.
Butter chicken at mild, yes, almost always. Mango Chicken, yes, and often more enthusiastically. Plain butter naan is a reliable win because it’s essentially warm bread. Steamed rice is safe. Gulab Jamun at the end has converted more children to Indian food than any curry ever has.
What to avoid for young kids: anything with madras or vindaloo in the name, Chilli Chicken Dry and Chilli Paneer Dry from the entrees (they are exactly what they say), and Laal Maas.
One honest note. Some kids react to the richness rather than the spice. Butter chicken has a lot of butter and cream in it, and a small child who eats a full serve will feel it. A shared serve with rice works better than a serve each.
Why some people still find it hot
A few reasons, and none of them are about chilli.
Ginger and garlic in quantity have their own bite, especially in the marinade. Black pepper and cloves create a warmth some people register as heat. And unfamiliarity plays a part, because if you’ve never eaten cardamom or fenugreek before, your brain files “intense new flavour” under “spicy” even when nothing is burning.
There’s also variation between kitchens. Butter chicken is the most-cooked Indian dish in this country and there’s no standard recipe. A place using a generic base gravy with a heavy hand on the chilli powder will produce something noticeably hotter than what we send out. That’s a fair reason to be cautious at an unfamiliar restaurant, but the dish itself is mild by design.
Frequently asked questions
Is butter chicken spicy for kids?
Not at mild, no. It’s the dish we recommend most often for children and it’s the one families order most at lunch. It’s sweet, creamy and mild. If your child is very sensitive, ask for it made without chilli entirely, and serve it with plain rice and butter naan rather than on its own.
Is butter chicken hotter than tikka masala?
No, tikka masala is hotter. Butter chicken is smooth and sweet with almost no chilli. Tikka masala uses more garam masala and more chilli, so there’s a real warmth to it, though it’s still mild by Indian standards. Both can be ordered at your preferred spice level at Ice n Spice.
Is butter chicken the mildest curry?
It’s the mildest thing on most Australian Indian menus. Korma is its main rival and some people find korma milder still, because it’s thickened with cashew and cream and has no tomato acidity. Vegetable Korma and Beef Korma are both on our menu if you want to compare them.
Can you make butter chicken hot?
Yes. We cook to order, so you can have it at mild, medium or hot. It keeps its creamy, sweet character and just gains chilli heat. If you want a dish that’s genuinely built around heat rather than one that’s had heat added, order Vindaloo, Madras or Laal Maas instead.
Why does butter chicken taste sweet?
Tomatoes cooked down slowly turn sweet, and butter and cream push it further. Some kitchens add sugar or honey as well. That sweetness is a real part of the dish, though in our view a lot of Australian versions have taken it too far and ended up closer to a dessert sauce than a curry.
What’s the mildest Indian dish for someone who hates spice?
Vegetable Korma, Butter Chicken or Mango Chicken. Malai Kofta is another good one, with vegetable and paneer dumplings in a creamy gravy. Add plain rice and a butter naan. We’ve compared the mild options properly in our mild Indian curry guide.
Does butter chicken have chilli in it at all?
A small amount, usually Kashmiri chilli, which is used for its deep red colour rather than heat. It’s one of the mildest chillies used in Indian cooking. If you need it completely chilli free, tell us when you order and we’ll cook it that way.
Is butter chicken the right order for a first-timer with low spice tolerance?
Yes, this is exactly the order for that. Butter chicken with steamed rice and a plain butter naan is the safest introduction to Indian food we can suggest, and most people who start there work their way across the menu over time. We’re fully licensed too, and a crisp lager sits well against the butter.
Does mild mean the flavour is weaker?
No, and this is worth saying clearly. Mild refers to chilli only. A well made mild curry has just as much cumin, coriander, cardamom and fenugreek in it as a hot one. Bland is a cooking failure, not a spice level.
Butter chicken sits in the non-veg mains section of our menu and we’ll cook it as mild as you want, including chilli free. If you’re ordering for a table where one person wants it gentle and someone else wants heat, get butter chicken and a Vindaloo and let everyone sort themselves out. That’s what most tables here end up doing.





